A small, dust-covered painting hanging in the hallway of a Michigan home, in the kind of overlooked spot buyers usually walk right past, sold for $1,352,600 at auction this month — a record for the artist, and roughly 45,000 times what the buyer originally paid for it.
Spotted In A “Dark Corner”
The painting turned up in July at an estate sale, tucked in a hallway leading to the garage, according to Freeman’s, the auction house that eventually brought it to market. Most shoppers at the sale had already passed it by.
An anonymous buyer, described by the auction house as a longtime hunter of record albums and mid-century furniture, noticed something in the painting’s lower-left corner: a faint signature reading “Abercrombie, ’51.” On that hunch alone, they paid the $30 asking price.
A Signature That Led To A Museum Catalog
The buyer’s research eventually led them to “Gertrude Abercrombie: The Whole World Is a Mystery,” a touring retrospective then showing at the Milwaukee Art Museum. There, in the exhibition catalog, they found a 1952 Chicago Tribune press clipping with a photograph of the exact painting they’d bought — shown alongside the real seashells it depicted.
That discovery was enough to formally pursue authentication. Susan Weininger, an art history professor at Roosevelt University and a leading Abercrombie scholar, confirmed the piece as genuine: an original 1951 oil titled “Alderman Merriam’s Shells,” still in its original frame.
Painted In 1951, Gifted In 1952, Lost For 75 Years
The painting depicts nine seashells belonging to Robert Merriam, who served as alderman of Chicago’s Fifth Ward — which included Hyde Park, where Abercrombie lived for most of her life — from 1947 to 1955. One of the shells in the painting, a nautilus, carries both a hole and a crack, which art historians say helped confirm Abercrombie was painting from a real, physical shell collection rather than inventing the imperfections, as had long been assumed about her work.
The piece was shown at several of Abercrombie’s exhibitions in Chicago, New York, and Milwaukee in 1952 and 1953, priced at the time between $50 and $150. It never sold. Instead, Abercrombie gave it to Dr. John Reynolds, a Kalamazoo physician, in exchange for medical care. It stayed with the Reynolds family for roughly 75 years, unseen publicly, until it resurfaced at this year’s estate sale.
From $30 To Record-Breaking
Before its restoration, art restorer Julian Baumgartner described the painting as “drab” and missing its life, obscured by grime and a clouded layer of old varnish — though structurally in what he called “perfect condition.” After cleaning and revarnishing, he said, “it’s alive and radiant.”
Freeman’s had estimated the painting would sell for between $150,000 and $250,000. Bidding blew past that range, closing at $1,352,600 — a new auction record for Abercrombie, surpassing the previous record of $1.02 million set in 2025 by her painting “Message for Mercy” at Sotheby’s.
Zachary Wirsum, Freeman’s senior vice president, said he’d told visitors on an exhibition tour just weeks earlier that Abercrombie paintings occasionally still turn up at estate sales. “Little did I know that one of those ‘once in a while’s would occur less than a month later,” he said.
Who Was Gertrude Abercrombie?
Abercrombie, who died in 1977 at age 68, was a largely self-taught Chicago painter known for sparse, dreamlike still lifes and surreal compositions — shells, owls, cats, and unexplained doorways set against stark, often black backdrops. She was also a fixture of Chicago’s midcentury jazz scene, hosting salons at her Hyde Park home attended by musicians including Dizzy Gillespie and Charlie Parker.
Shells were a recurring and deeply personal motif in her work. “I always paint myself,” she once said of her art, and Freeman’s suggests the shells in particular may have functioned as a kind of talisman, often gifted to people close to her — much as “Alderman Merriam’s Shells” began as a gift rather than a sale.
Frequently Asked Questions
How much did the painting sell for?
$1,352,600 at Freeman’s Post-War & Contemporary Art auction — a new record for Gertrude Abercrombie’s work.
How did the buyer know it might be valuable?
They noticed a faint signature reading “Abercrombie, ’51” and later found a matching archival photo of the painting in a museum exhibition catalog, which led to formal authentication.
Who authenticated the painting?
Susan Weininger, an art history professor at Roosevelt University and a recognized expert on Abercrombie’s work.
Why had the painting been unseen for so long?
Abercrombie gave it to a Kalamazoo doctor in 1952 in exchange for medical care. It remained with his family for about 75 years before surfacing at this year’s estate sale.
Who is Gertrude Abercrombie?
A largely self-taught Chicago surrealist painter (1909–1977), known for dreamlike still lifes and for hosting jazz salons attended by musicians like Dizzy Gillespie and Charlie Parker.
Is this her most expensive painting ever sold?
Yes, as of this sale. It surpassed the previous record of $1.02 million, set in 2025 by her painting “Message for Mercy” at Sotheby’s.
Sources: Smithsonian Magazine, Hoodline, BroBible, Good News Network, and Freeman’s Auctions.
Leave a Reply