Throughout history, sailors have mistaken Beluga Whales for mermaids because of their human-like knees

For centuries, the fog-drenched logs of maritime explorers were filled with accounts of elusive sea creatures—beings with the grace of a fish and the unmistakable form of a human. While many of these sightings were dismissed as the hallucinations of salt-fatigued men, modern biology suggests the sailors weren’t just seeing things. They were looking at the Beluga whale.

But it wasn’t just a flash of white skin or a haunting song that fooled them. It was something far more uncanny: the appearance of human knees.

The Anatomical Illusion

At first glance, the idea of a whale having knees sounds like a biological impossibility. Indeed, whales do not have knee joints in the way primates do; their ancestors traded hind limbs for powerful tail flukes millions of years ago.

However, the Beluga (Delphinapterus leucas) possesses a unique physiological trait. To survive the sub-zero temperatures of the Arctic, these whales carry an exceptionally thick layer of blubber (vascularized fat). When a Beluga moves its lower body or maneuvers in shallow water, this heavy fat can fold and contract in a way that creates distinct, bony-looking protrusions.

To a 17th-century sailor peering over the gunwale of a wooden ship, these blubber-folds looked identical to the muscular definition of human legs and knees tucked beneath a ghostly white torso.

The “Canaries of the Sea”

The deception went beyond the visual. Belugas are famously known as the “Canaries of the Sea” due to their sophisticated vocal range.

• Vocal Mimicry: They produce high-pitched whistles, chirps, and even sounds that mimic human conversation or distant singing.
• The Mobile Neck: Unlike almost all other whale species, the Beluga’s neck vertebrae are not fused. This allows them to nod and turn their heads with a range of motion that is eerily human-like, further cementing the “mermaid” persona in the minds of superstitious mariners.

A Case of Biological Pareidolia

Psychologists call this phenomenon pareidolia—the human tendency to see familiar patterns (like faces or bodies) where they don’t exist. In the lonely, treacherous stretches of the North Atlantic, the Beluga provided the perfect canvas for this psychological trick.

“The Beluga is perhaps the most ‘expressive’ of all cetaceans,” says one marine biologist. “Between their facial expressions and the way their blubber shifts to mimic limbs, it’s entirely logical that an ancient sailor would see a reflection of themselves in the water.”

Legacy of the Legend

Today, we know the “knees” are simply an evolutionary masterpiece of insulation and hydrodynamics. Yet, when a Beluga rises to the surface, tilts its head to look you in the eye, and reveals the muscular contours of its lower body, the line between science and myth still feels wonderfully thin.

The mermaid may not be real, but the creature that inspired her is far more fascinating than the legend itself.